Happy Thanksgiving–even if you’re not a white middle-class American
Posted by James McPherson on November 24, 2011
Above is a classic 1951 expression of what some of the things we have to be thankful for today as Americans (assuming we’re not those Native Americans typically cast as Pilgrim Squanto/Tonto helpmates in the traditional Thanksgiving saga, before William Bradford and other Colonial forefathers were expressing thanks that they could kill so many Indians.
Below are some highlights of the video, along with my related comments:
Expressing thanks for the “free public library,” public education and “hot water out of the tap”?
Sounds like socialism to me.
Thankful to “be able to go to any church I want”? Even one that’s not Christian? Hmm.
“For living where schools–all schools–open their doors to a guy who wants to learn”?
Well, a white guy, anyway, here in 1951.
“Thankful that my children have the privilege of being born safely, and of growing up healthy and strong”?
Not as privileged as kids in Canada or Australia or New Zealand or virtually any European nation, but much better than if they were poor or non-white Americans.
“Glad Dad doesn’t have to work slave hours, that there are evenings and Sundays and vacations when we can all be together”?
And so thank God for the unions that brought us those things?
Thankful for “a place we can be together in privacy” and “knowing the knock on our door is nothing to fear”?
At least for most white middle-class Americans, before the Patriot Act.
“And I’m thankful for my newspaper … more valuable than any amount of money, because in it the editor’s got the privilege of printing what he thinks, and I’ve got the privilege of agreeing with him or not, however the facts strike me.”
“And finally, I’m thankful for being able to believe, in spite of everything, that somehow, some way, the unity we’ve got here in the Johnson family will someday spread to men and nations throughout the world.”
However delusional the thought: Amen.